Kyle Schwarber has constructed a very compelling Hall of Fame case through the first 12 years of his MLB career – though there are still several factors weighing him down.
Looking back on an MLB Draft class viewed by many to be among the weakest in recent memory, it almost feels strange that three teams still passed up on the opportunity to add Kyle Schwarber to their organization.
Selected by the Chicago Cubs with the fourth overall pick in the 2014 MLB Draft initially as a catcher, the Indiana alum was widely viewed as the most polished hitter in the draft – which held up, as only three pitchers were selected ahead of the lefty slugger.
Within just a year, Schwarber was up contributing with the big league team, slotting in temporarily with Miguel Montero and David Ross as the Cubs’ third catcher while picking up some familiarity with the outfield as well. Schwarber, just 22 years old at the time, went on to hit 16 home runs during his rookie season, incredibly adding five more during the Cubs’ postseason run to the NLCS.
From that point, the rest is history.
Schwarber, now 33, is arguably the premier pure power hitter of this generation with a career full of accolades many incredible players never reach. Despite missing virtually all of the 2016 season with a torn ACL, Schwarber triumphantly returned to the Cubs as a designated hitter during the World Series, playing an indispensable role in what is perhaps the most famous World Series victory in the sport’s history.
While Schwarber remained a formidable power hitter with the Cubs for the following few seasons, the North Siders inexplicably parted ways with the slugger after an underwhelming 2020 season, kickstarting the current era of his career that has seen him reach a new level of dominance.
Schwarber was named to the All-Star team in 2021, spending much of the year with the Washington Nationals before being dealt to the Boston Red Sox at the trade deadline, where he would get his first action as a first baseman.
Yet much of what Schwarber will be remembered for has taken place in Philadelphia, where the power hitter has spent the past five seasons of his career. In that time, Schwarber has hit 222 home runs in a Phillies uniform, made the playoffs every season and set a new career-high with 56 home runs in a 2025 campaign that saw him finish as the NL MVP runner-up to Shohei Ohtani.
Though always able to draw a walk, Schwarber has truly grown into a true three-outcome player during his time in Philadelphia, having led the NL in home runs and strikeouts on three occasions since joining the team (including this year) while also leading the league in walks once as well.
When taking his playoff performance into account, Schwarber’s case for Cooperstown only strengthens further. Schwarber’s 23 postseason home runs are tied with George Springer for third all-time, only trailing Jose Altuve and Manny Ramirez.
Schwarber has also homered in every possible round of the postseason in both leagues – going deep in an AL and NL Wild Card Game while also taking the ball out of the park in an ALDS, NLDS, ALCS, NLCS and World Series (you can add the World Baseball Classic too, for good measure).
So why isn’t Kyle Schwarber a crystal clear case for the Hall of Fame in the way that many hitters with his power in the past have been?
Ultimately, baseball has greatly changed over the last 25 years – with more value and attention being placed on the other aspects of the game, largely thanks to the advent of sabermetrics that help quantify things that previously didn’t have a spot on the stat sheet.
Of course, no stat has become as ubiquitous or all-encompassing as wins above replacement, or WAR – a stat that aims to measure how many wins a player contributed to a team in a given year compared to a generic replacement-level player. Taking offense, defense and baserunning into account, WAR helps shine a light on some players who are contributing much more than their counting stats suggest, while also highlighting the drawbacks to some of the game’s more one-dimensional players, Schwarber being among them.
Much of what WAR gets into can be reflected in the traditional five tools of baseball – contact hitting, power hitting, baserunning, glove/range and arm strength.
Of course, it doesn’t take a dedicated baseball historian to figure out that Kyle Schwarber really only excels in one of these five areas, while posting relatively poor metrics across the other four – which shows in Schwarber’s career WAR.
Despite his wide range of accolades, Kyle Schwarber enters play on Aug. 13, 2026 with a career WAR of 22.5 – certainly a solid contribution that doesn’t grow on trees, but one that pales in comparison even to players that Schwarber is universally viewed as better than.
Take a look at two of Schwarber’s former teammates in Ian Happ and Nico Hoerner, both of whom debuted well after Schwarber (Happ in 2017, Hoerner in 2019). Despite the later starts to their careers and more muted reputation across baseball, the two longtime Cubs have career WARs of 24.7 and 24.1 respectively – which can be attributed to their excellent defense, as well as Hoerner’s contact hitting and base-stealing ability.
When looking at the other areas of the game, Schwarber is simply no superstar. With a career .233 batting average, he isn’t exactly the guy to rely on for a base hit – with his average having widely varied throughout his career as well. While Schwarber has hit as high as .266 in a season and is currently hitting a respectable .248, he has also posted a season average as low as .197 – a year in which he inexplicably received MVP votes! (This will certainly be a topic for my Season Spotlight series one day)
Given his size, injury history and past as a catcher, Schwarber is also no speedster – although he has recorded 10 stolen bases in a season on two separate occasions.
But perhaps most notable when looking at why Schwarber’s WAR is so low relative to other hitters of his caliber is the defense – or lack thereof.
While Schwarber has greatly benefited from the leaguewide addition of the designated hitter in 2022, he has plenty of experience playing the field – which included remaining the Phillies’ everyday left fielder throughout 2022 and much of 2023.
Though known as perhaps the least-demanding defensive position, Schwarber simply never came into his own as an outfielder – clocking in at -13.7 dWAR for his career, with Schwarber measuring -2.8 dWAR in 2023 alone.
Although Schwarber isn’t actively hurting his team defensively as a full-time designated hitter, it does still negatively impact his defensive WAR, as the average replacement-level player still contributes defensively – a phenomenon that has dragged down the dWAR of Shohei Ohtani throughout his career as well.
None of this is to say that Kyle Schwarber is overrated (he is not in the slightest) or that he isn’t worthy of the praise and accolades he receives – but rather just how much has changed when it comes to evaluating the careers of baseball players, even if it’s well beyond the days of their playing careers.
When I was growing up, I always heard from my dad and many other dedicated baseball fans that there were three statistical milestones that would guarantee election to the Baseball Hall of Fame without exception – 500 home runs, 3,000 hits and 300 wins.
A quarter-century later, and things have drastically changed. While 3,000 hits for a player who wasn’t juiced remains an essential guarantee, the steroid era shifted the perception of what 500 home runs means – even expanding well beyond just considering whether a player was juiced or not when hitting the home runs.
Much of this can be attributed to how much offense has changed. For much of the sport’s history that included my early childhood, batting average was the preeminent offensive statistic that literally determined if players would keep their jobs.
While this meant that you could usually survive as a .230 hitter with little-to-no power, hitters hovering around .200 were often given no grace – regardless of what their power contribution looked like.
Yet in the era of the three outcomes of walk, strikeout and home run, the perception of batting average has greatly shifted as the importance of the statistic has fallen. In today’s game, the Neifi Perez-type player who solidly hits above .200 but does so with essentially no power or ability to get on base is virtually extinct, unless that player also has extremely elite defense and/or baserunning.
On the other hand, today’s game is the kind of game that allowed a .197 hitting Kyle Schwarber to finish 19th in NL MVP voting in 2023, despite the fact that he would be getting hounded by the press for his poor average regardless of the 47 home runs he hit.
But of course, that’s a bit revisionist in and of itself, as players like Schwarber simply didn’t exist during that era – as players such as Adam Dunn paved the way for the current dynamic of power-hitting that exists in today’s game.
As far as the Hall of Fame goes, voters are probably arriving at wildly different conclusions when it comes to the veracity of his candidacy. With 60 WAR serving as a general benchmark for the Hall of Fame (although several players with lower WARs have made it in), Schwarber’s prowess as a power-hitter will have to do extremely heavy lifting when it comes to his Hall of Fame case.
Of course, WAR isn’t everything, even nowadays, when it comes to evaluating whether a player is fit for Cooperstown or not. While players such as David Cone (62.3), Jim Edmonds (60.4) and Mark Buehrle (59.0) have received relatively little consideration for the Hall, while Jeff Kent (55.4), Fred McGriff (52.6) and Jack Morris (43.5) have made their way in.
Though it’s mostly older players that dominate the list of Hall of Famers with comparatively low WARs, one modern example comes with Yadier Molina, a player widely expected to be inducted into the Hall of Fame despite a career WAR of 41.6 – which is lower than Jason Kendall, Placido Polanco and Jorge Posada.
While I love to call Molina overrated, his Hall of Fame case has the necessary teeth to overcome the lower WAR. He’s a two-time World Series champion with durability that is unmatched in today’s era of catching, while serving as the sport’s premier game-caller behind the plate throughout much of his career.
Kyle Schwarber’s current Hall of Fame case is similar in the sense that it has a lot of what it needs to overcome the lower WAR, especially given Schwarber’s titanic playoff legacy.
But still, getting into the Hall of Fame with 41.6 WAR is much, much different than knocking on the door with a career WAR over five wins behind Rondell White and Jarrod Washburn.
At 33 years old, Schwarber is not going to start playing the field and blossom into a defensive star out of nowhere, nor will he maintain the power he has now while posting a .300 batting average in the way that Aaron Judge and Albert Pujols can. Schwarber’s Hall of Fame case solely rests on his herculean ability to hit home runs and his ability to do so on baseball’s biggest stage.
Therefore, the goalposts should be a bit different for Schwarber, and I’m not fully convinced that 500 home runs alone with his postseason resume standing where it does at the moment is enough to warrant an addition to Cooperstown.
But at 33 years old as a full-time designated hitter, Schwarber has plenty of time left to continue to strengthen his case. For me, Schwarber does cross that threshold if he goes on to reach 600 home runs, a milestone only nine players ever have reached, as well as if he goes on to win another World Series while contributing greatly along the way.
I think with the extreme exclusivity of 600 home runs, there is no WAR low enough to keep him out – with the same argument available if Schwarber is able to construct another amazing postseason that ends in a World Series ring.
There’s no telling how voters will react to Kyle Schwarber’s candidacy when it’s all said and done, but it’s clear that his unique career will force voters to think about Cooperstown in a way that they never have before.
Leave a Reply